BPMN vs Flowchart vs Activity Diagram: A Comprehensive Review

Table of Contents hide

1 Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN)

Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN), Flowcharts, and Activity Diagrams are three popular tools used for modeling and visualizing processes. Each has its own strengths and is suited to different types of tasks. Below is a comprehensive review of these three tools, including key concepts, examples, and a comparison table.

Business Process Model and Notation (BPMN)

Key Concepts:

Process: A sequence of activities performed to achieve a specific goal.
Events: Something that happens during a process (e.g., start, end, intermediate events).
Activities: Work performed within a process (e.g., tasks, sub-processes).
Gateways: Decision points that determine the flow of the process (e.g., exclusive, inclusive, parallel gateways).
Flow Objects: Includes events, activities, and gateways.
Connecting Objects: Includes sequence flow, message flow, and associations.
Swimlanes: Used to organize activities into separate categories, often representing different roles or departments.

Example:

Consider a simple order processing system:

Start Event: Order Received
Task: Verify Order
Exclusive Gateway: Is Order Valid?
- Yes: Proceed to “Prepare Order”
- No: Proceed to “Notify Customer”
Task: Prepare Order
Task: Ship Order
End Event: Order Completed

Flowchart

Key Concepts:

Start/End: Indicates the beginning and end of a process.
Process: Represents a task or activity.
Decision: Represents a point where a decision is made, usually leading to different paths.
Input/Output: Represents data entering or leaving the process.
Flowlines: Arrows that indicate the direction of the process flow.

Example:

A simple flowchart for a customer support process:

Start: Customer Calls
Process: Answer Call
Decision: Is Issue Resolved?
- Yes: Proceed to “End Call”
- No: Proceed to “Escalate Issue”
Process: Escalate Issue
Process: Resolve Issue
End: End Call

Activity Diagram

Key Concepts:

Initial Node: Represents the start of the workflow.
Activity: Represents a task or action.
Decision Node: Represents a branching point based on a condition.
Merge Node: Combines multiple incoming flows into one.
Fork/Join: Splits a flow into multiple concurrent flows (fork) and synchronizes them back into one (join).
Final Node: Represents the end of the workflow.
Swimlanes: Used to group activities based on responsibility or role.

Example:

An activity diagram for a software development process:

Initial Node: Start
Activity: Requirements Gathering
Activity: Design
Fork: Split into parallel activities
- Activity: Coding
- Activity: Testing
Join: Synchronize coding and testing
Decision Node: Is Software Acceptable?
- Yes: Proceed to “Deployment”
- No: Proceed to “Revise Requirements”
Activity: Deployment
Final Node: End

Comparison Table

Feature	BPMN	Flowchart	Activity Diagram
Purpose	Modeling business processes	Visualizing algorithms and processes	Modeling workflows and operations
Complexity	High	Low to Medium	Medium to High
Standardization	Standardized by OMG	No standardization	Standardized by OMG
Use Cases	Business process management	Simple processes, algorithms	Software development, workflows
Notation	Rich set of symbols	Simple set of symbols	Rich set of symbols
Decision Points	Gateways	Decision boxes	Decision nodes
Concurrency	Supported	Not supported	Supported
Swimlanes	Yes	No	Yes
Events	Start, end, intermediate events	Start/End symbols	Initial/Final nodes
Tool Support	Many BPMN tools available	Basic drawing tools	UML tools

Conclusion

BPMN, Flowcharts, and Activity Diagrams each serve different purposes and are suited to different types of tasks. BPMN is ideal for complex business processes, Flowcharts are great for simple algorithms and processes, and Activity Diagrams are well-suited for modeling software development workflows. Understanding the strengths and limitations of each tool can help you choose the right one for your specific needs.