What is Interrelationship Diagram?

An Interrelationship Diagram is a visual display that maps out the cause and effect links among complex, multivariable problems or desired outcomes. With the linked connections, you can better analyze the cause-and-effect relationships that exist among all factors of a complex situation, which, ultimately, allowing you to develop an effective solution to the problem. You can logically link more than one factor at a time. Thus, this process encourages you to think in multiple directions instead of thinking linearly. Once all the relevant connections between items have been drawn, the connections are counted. Those with the most connections will usually be the most important factors to focus on.

When to Use an Interrelationship Diagram?

  • Encourages Team Members To Think In Multiple Directions Rather Than Linearly
  • Explores The Cause And Effect Relationships Among All The Issues, Including The Most Controversial
  • Allows Key Issues To Emerge Naturally Rather Than To Be Forced By A Dominant Or Powerful Team Member
  • Systematically Surfaces The Basic Assumptions And Reasons For Disagreements Among Team Members
  • Allows A Team To Identify The Root Cause(S) Even When Credible Data Does Not Exist

Steps for Creating Interrelationship Diagram

To create an Interrelationship Diagram, it is important to write a statement that defines the issue of the problem going to be explored. Team members need to brainstorm ideas and write them around the main issues. Once the ideas are placed on the issue, connecting ideas using arrows to establish their relationship.

To create an Interrelationship Diagram:

  1. Identify the issue or question.
  2. Add issues / influences / Causes of the problem
  3. Compare each element to all others. Use an “influence” arrow to connect related elements.
  4. The arrows should be drawn from the element that influences the one influenced.
  5. If two elements influence each other, the arrow should be drawn to reflect the stronger influence.
  6. Count the arrows.
  7. The elements with the most outgoing arrows will be root causes or drivers.
  8. The ones with the most incoming arrows will be key outcomes or results.

Interrelationship Diagram Example — High Waiting Time for Buses

Edit this Diagram

*Source: whatissixsigma.net

Analyze the Diagram

  • Count The Number Of Input And Output (Input/Output) Arrows On Each Card And Annotate It In One Of Its Corners.
  • If An Element Causes Many Others: These Are The Main Causes.
  • If An Element Is Touched By Many Arrows: It Represents The Final Effects.
  • Those Elements That Concentrate A Lot Of Incoming And Outgoing Arrows: They Are Key Elements.

Interrelationship Diagram Example — Product Shipping Poor Communication

This example is taken from *Benbow and Kubiak in 2005). Now, let’s interpret the meaning of the diagram, so, what are the key factors or causes to investigate and improve?

Edit this Diagram

Recall that:

Identify the Key Cause (Driver)

We called the entries in the digraph concerns. A concern with a high number of output arrows is a driver or key cause. A key cause affects a large number of other items. The above diagram shows the following key causes:

  1. ‘Poor scheduling practices’ (6 outgoing arrows),
  2. ‘Late order from the customer’ (5 outgoing arrows), and
  3. ‘Equipment breakdown (3 outgoing arrows).

Identify the Key Concern

  • A Concern With A Large Number Of Input Arrows Is Affected By A Large Number Of Other Concerns. Thus, It Could Be A Source Of A Quality Or Performance Metric.
  • ‘Poor Scheduling Of The Trucker’ Has 4 Input Arrows.
  • A Measure Of Poor Scheduling Performance Of The Trucker Could Indicate The Magnitude Of System Problems Causing Late Delivery.
  • Benbow, D. W., and T. M. Kubiak — The Certified Six Sigma Black Belt Handbook. Milwaukee, Wisconsin, ASQ Quality Press in 2005.

Examples:

Edit this Diagram

Interrelationship Diagram Example — Corporate Change Program

The following is an example of an interrelationship diagram that was created to help a team identify why a change initiative within an organization has failed to bring the anticipated benefits. Optionally, the diagram can put the totals of the incoming and outgoing arrows on the top of each item.

Edit this Diagram

Business Interrelationship Diagram Example

Interrelationship Diagram Example — Small Hospital

(*Source — PMI’s Business Analysis Guide)

small hospital was concerned about the productivity of its doctors because they were the most expensive employees and critical for the treatment of the patients. Having taken numerous steps toward ensuring high productivity, hospital management was baffled when productivity steadily declined month after month.

Since this development was unexplainable, management sought to gain insight into causes and effects among the different factors at play. They decided to create an interrelationship diagram and include the following factors in the analysis:

  • The Number Of Scheduled Appointments Per Doctor
  • The Number Of Emergency Appointments Per Doctor
  • Administrative Workload Per Doctor
  • The Number Of Changes In Scheduled Appointments
  • Equipment Quality And Reliability
  • Nurse Availability
  • Availability Of Other Support Functions
  • The Doctors’ Pay Levels

Edit this Diagram

Interpreting the Diagram Result

A high number of outgoing arrows indicate that an issue is a driver or possible root cause. The team generally evaluates these issues first to gain the most far-reaching results. A high number of incoming arrows indicates that an issue is an outcome. These issues may serve as important measures of success.

  • Count The Arrows In And Out For Each Idea. Write The Counts At The Bottom Of Each Box. The Ones With The Most Arrows Are The Key Ideas.
  • Note Which Ideas Have Primarily Outgoing (From) Arrows. These Are Basic Causes Or Drivers.
  • Note Which Ideas Have Primarily Incoming (To) Arrows. These Are Final Effects That Also May Be Critical To Address.
  • Be Sure To Check Whether Ideas With Fewer Arrows Also Are Key Ideas. The Number Of Arrows Is Only An Indicator, Not An Absolute Rule. Draw Bold Lines Around The Key Ideas.

7 komentarzy

Leave a Reply

Twój adres e-mail nie zostanie opublikowany.